Why do "secret" fishing holes matter? Well, they matter because "non-secret" holes get fished hard and often, maybe until they lose their status as a fishing hole at all. My brother (in-law) and fishing buddy told me about a "secret" hole 3 months ago. He boasted of 5-6 pound rainbows that were both hungry and willing. I am always a bit skeptical about the validity of fishing claims. Anyone can talk a good game about trophy fish - catching them is an entirely different story. Dishonesty, or to put it in a more mild way "truth-stretching", has been in the DNA of fishermen of all sorts down through the millennia of time. But this fishing buddy wisely took pictures of the evidence to prove of the worth of this particular hole.
Needless to say, I was impressed. He wasn't stretching the truth on this river Needless to say, I wanted in. Luckily he obliged and he let me join.
I can only tell you that this secret hole is a creek in the vicinity of Island Park, ID. That's all you get because that's all I'm permitted to share. But I respect the "why" of keeping certain fishing places secret. After all, I have seen lesser known fishing creeks that held some big trout in Utah become overrun in a couple of years after official "discovery". It's a sad process to witness nature getting trampled through over-use, even abuse. So I hope this particular creek doesn't lose it's luster and get overrun by over-eager fishermen. Currently, you have to pay $100 for a full day of fishing on this river and they only allow 10 people per day to fish on it. Maybe the entry fee will dissuade some of the fishing hoard from Salt Lake City from coming, not to mention the 4-hour drive. After all, not everyone is willing to "pay to play" when it comes to fly fishing.
Don't ask where this spot is located (Keeping Secrets). Do let me tell you how the fishing was (Catching Lunkers).
Bruce invited me to join his family on a final fishing trip for the summer before the cold weather set in. We arrived on Thursday night in a cozy rental cabin outside of Island Park. The next morning, we were out the door by 8:30 am, and on this special creek by 9:30 am. We split into 2 groups: Bruce and Christy on the lower end of the river, while Boston and Max and myself hit the upper end of the river.
As I approached the first hole, I first noticed how crystal clear this water was. Then I saw large black shadows in the water that looked to be between 2-3 feet long. Submerged logs? Rock structures? Moss banks? Visions in my head? I couldn't and wouldn't believe they were trout at first. But after further study, taking my glasses off, and making sure I wasn't still sleeping, it was true - they most definitely were. Huge, well-colored, hefty rainbow trout silently lurked in the deep holes of this special creek.
 |
First glimpse at The Aquarium - full of trophy trout!
|
I was officially excited - the game was on. "The Talk" on this stream was about to become "The Walk!"
I have found that it is most convenient to have two different set-ups on two different fishing poles in situations where you're trying to figure out what the fish are eating on a new river. It saves so much time to not have to constantly be switching out flies and tippet going from a streamer to a nymph to a dry and back to a streamer again, depending on what kind of water you were working. So I prepared and carried a rod dedicated to streamer fishing and a rod dedicated to hopper/dropper fishing. I switched them off regularly. It turns out, everything was working for a few magical hours that morning. The larger fish (14-20") took the brown/orange Ugly Bugger. The smaller fish (6-10") took the Hare's Ear nymph and the Parachute Hopper. Both types of fish knew what they wanted.
We fished upstream 0.5 miles and were having a blast. Once a hole produced a fish, we kept moving onward. These were definitely "one and done" type of fish. The hole needed time to "reset" after all the commotion of a caught fish. The only downside I had was a nagging cold. It sapped my energy, both mentally and physically - both were needed when you're on technical fishing waters from dawn until dusk.
 |
These fish were all footballs.
|
Around lunchtime, we met up with Bruce and Christy and found that they had been landing some lunkers on their section as well that morning. The same pattern held true for them: the big fish wanted streamers, the smaller fish settled for nymphs. Granted, we had to work to figure out the color and size of streamer the fish wanted, but they certainly did want streamers. Not much dry fly action in the morning.
That all changed after lunch though - in a big way.
We journeyed 0.5 mile down to the lower section of this creek. Bruce calls this section the area where "the athletes" dwell. I had never considered a fish an athlete before. But it didn't take long for me to learn what he meant exactly. I tied on a different size hopper for the afternoon fishing session. On my very first cast in a rippled pool, I had the most violent take of the day. An angry fish slammed my hopper, fought for maybe 3 heartbeats, and was gone - with a hopper hook embedded in his lip. I was shocked. Everyone else decided to switch to large terrestrials as well.
 |
| Max braving the Teton River crossing. |
We then separated and fished our way upstream in 2 groups once again. The next 3 hours were the most productive for all of us.
Christy has really come around as a fine fly fisherwoman. The last time I fished her was approximately 3 decades ago, when were both professional worm dunkers. She caught 3 on the Chubby Chernobyl, and missed a few more. She fished with a lot of zeal and zest, appropriately.
 |
Christy has the "fish pose" for pictures down.
|
Boston actually stayed with streamers here for a while, but then ultimately switched over to dry flies as well. He says he caught the largest rainbow of his life on a black woolly bugger on this section. He has really progressed as a 14-year old fly-fisherman. Impressive.
 |
A sweet rainbow by Boston.
|
 |
Boston's nice bow caught in the aquarium, the toughest hole of all.
|
Bruce caught a few of his "athletes" on large dries as well on this section, not to mention some additional hogs he caught that morning on the streamer. He did a nice job guiding and working with each of us, while still getting in some good fishing. It was his 4th time on this very river in a relatively short time frame, and it showed.
 |
Bruce's athlete fish.
|
Speaking of guiding, Bruce worked directly with Max to catch some nice ones back in a hole I calledTorpedo Alley. Before then, Max was specializing in catching various forms of fish bait: frogs, lizards, insects, and small minnow-trout. He was relieved to have finally found his groove and caught some healthy rainbows by the end of the day.
 |
There you go - Max's afternoon lunker!
|
 |
Max's most creative catch.
|
 |
Max's morning lunker.
|
 |
Very cool underwater release.
|
As for me, I just stayed focused on not spooking fish on this section and giving clean presentations. It finally paid off with a few nice fish on dries towards the end of this stretch. Regrettably, I lost 2 more large fish due to weak tippet and an over-aggressive hook set on my part. One occurred on my first cast. So I haven't been thinking about just "the one that got away", but instead "the 3 that got away." Ouch to my delicate fishing ego!
 |
Mid-morning rainbow, caught on the Ugly Butter.
|
 |
Admiring a real wild beauty...
|
 |
Such beautiful colors...
|
After a quick dinner consisting of road snacks and PB & Js from the cooler, we decided to try our hand at the lake. The secret creek flows into this lake, making it a secret lake. We were there right at sunset and the after-glowing dusk. We saw a few sporadic rise forms on the lake, and actually had 2 takes on our flies, but couldn't set the hook. While it was gorgeous, it reminded me why I prefer fly fishing on rivers over lakes 99 times out of 100: more fun (funner?), more action, more engaging, more interesting, more dynamic, more rewarding. The coolest part of that particular lake was the amazing and distinct echo we heard as we yelled different noises into the fading light - it was like something out of the movies.
 |
Bruce and Christy showing nice teamwork on the release of her rainbow.
|
 |
Christy and Bruce sharing a moment - who thought fly fishing could be so romantic?
|
All in all, it was an 11-hour fishing day with 9 large fish in the net is definitely worth my $100.
On day 2 (Saturday), we had a nice leisure morning where we all slept in, went on a jog, and packed up. After going to the local fly shop in Island Park for a recommendation from the locals, we were directed to try the Teton River. (Because this is not a secret creek but rather a public river, I can certainly share the name of this body of water :)). It is located on the west side of the Tetons - typically home to some of the best alpine views in all of the West. One of the few regrets I had for the entire trip was that the wildfire smoke was so intense that the views of the back side of the Grand Tetons was totally obscured.
Once we finally got down to the river, Boston had his first fish on within minutes - on his first cast to be exact. He caught a healthy pan-fry cutthroat trout on a streamer.
 |
Boston showing off his cutt - caught 30 seconds after arriving!
|
We were all amped to be on this river, even though there was some inevitable bushwhacking to be had.
 |
The high grasses along the banks of the Teton.
|
I caught another one on a dry, as did Bruce. Unfortunately, that was all the luck we had on the Teton River for that day. While we didn't catch many fish on Saturday, we still "caught" many beautiful views of a remote canyon gorge, while relaxing with family and basking in nature.
 |
| Max working the upper section. |
All in all, it was a trip to remember, even if I can't tell you the name of where we really were.
 |
| Well colored rainbows make a good memory. |
 |
We will come back for these lunkers another day...
|